Matt
Corral
Junior
QB
Ole Miss
Rebels
Ole Miss Rebels Logo
HEIGHT 6' 1 5/8" HANDS 9 5/8"
WEIGHT 212 lbs CONE --
40 TIME -- BROAD --
Strengths
  • Quick athletic feet with some twitch to his movement. Tight-snap compact delivery with little range of motion
  • Showed good balance with firm base on his set in the pocket. Subtle movement to reset his feet when needed
  • RPO concepts a significant part of Ole Miss pass game, and Corral executed them effectively with precision throws
  • Bang play action also featured part of Ole Miss pass game with OG pulling in power look: quick game, one read
  • Precise ball location in short and intermediate pass game, especially between the numbers. Confident thrower
  • Gives an offense designed QB run game featuring zone read, QB power, QB draw. Good athlete with light feet
  • Aggressive and competitive runner with physical toughness. Did not always look to go down to give himself up
  • Highly competitive with outstanding playing personality. Competes every snap. Mentally and physically tough
Weaknesses
  • Lacks desired/ideal height with small frame, but that is not as critical to many in QB evaluation as it used to be
  • One-arm-angle thrower given tight delivery with almost no range of motion. Cannot manipulate arm angle
  • Struggled at times to see it and read it when quick rhythm timing throws were not there. Vision must improve
  • Left throws on the field that were there to be made when he saw a running lane. Needs more pocket patience
  • Needs to be taught much more about the concepts of NFL passing games and full field progression reads
  • Limited experience in the drop-back passing game and the protection concepts that go with it. Must be taught
  • Arm strength and ball placement suffered when he was forced to sit on back foot and go late in the down
  • Took far too many hits and shots, running both by design and second reaction. That will have to change in NFL
Other
  • Corral played four years at Ole Miss after coming out of southern California as a consensus 4-star recruit and a top 100 prospect nationally. Corral started four games in 2019 and became the full-time starter in 2020 throwing for more than 6600 yards and 49 TD in his final two seasons.
  • The Ole Miss pass game was high percentage shotgun with play action and RPO concepts that defined reads and throws for Corral within timing and structure of the play concept. Corral played very limited snaps under center and very little straight drop back. Lane Kiffin featured some foundational NFL pass game concepts like flood opposite with vertical-cross combination (Sanders 28 yards versus Louisville).
  • Corral will not be able to run in the NFL the way he ran at Ole Miss in terms of volume and style. He was a physical and competitive runner who often looked to lower his shoulder and initiate contact.
  • Sanders 59 yards versus Arkansas, Corral threw the ball 62 yards in the air from a clean pocket. Impressive.
Transition

Corral is a shorter than ideally desired, small-frame QB whose 2020 and 2021 tape showed a twitchy athlete with a plus arm with the ability to effectively work all three levels of the defense, in addition to an active, mobile player who brought a playmaking dimension with his second-reaction running ability. Corral ran a highly schemed, tempo, high-percentage defined-one-read pass game with a strong emphasis on quick rhythm throws off play action/RPO acton, with little straight drop back pass until down and distance or game situation demanded it (tempo element regulated the defense and more often than not gave Corral a clean pre-snap read). Corral showed a quick, compact release and he consistently saw it fast and turned it loose with velocity on the defined one-read concepts that were the foundation of the Ole Miss pass game. What Corral needs to learn are full-field progression concepts that you can incorporate and integrate with the spread RPO and play action elements that he is most familiar and most comfortable with. His development at the next level will be a function of how quickly he can learn how to read it out from the pocket and how fast he can see it on pro pass game concepts. One thing is certain as you project and transition Corral to the NFL, and that is he will not be featured on designed runs the way he was at Ole Miss.

Kaleb
Eleby
Sophomore
QB
Western Michigan
Broncos
Western Michigan Broncos Logo
HEIGHT 6' 0 3/4" HANDS 9 1/4"
WEIGHT 208 lbs CONE --
40 TIME -- BROAD 111"
Strengths
  • Efficient drop and set with quick feet, good ball carriage, and plant foot for weight transfer and core torque
  • Played consistently and efficiently within timing and rhythmic structure of the highly defined WMU pass game
  • Showed a good feel for the timing on defined-read intermediate throws, both inside and outside the numbers
  • Ball placement a strength of his game. Consistently made the right kind of throw with precise location
  • Showed controlled pocket movement when demanded, maintaining vision down the field in position to throw
  • Flashed late in the down poise in the pocket. Snaps in which he was comfortable showing progression reading
  • Saw the field well in the dropback passing game. A sense of coverage and coverage rotation, dictating throws
  • Made some tough throws under duress. Flashed pocket toughness to stand firm and make contested throws
  • Showed functional second reaction movement to plays outside of structure despite not being a dynamic or explosive athlete
Weaknesses
  • A bit of an over-strider at times, which put too much weight on his front foot then forced his arm to catch up
  • Some arm strength limitations. What stood out at times was some deeper throws lost energy on the back end
  • Inconsistent lower-body mechanics which negatively impacted ability to drive the ball and make deeper throws
  • Questions as to his ability to function effectively in contested pockets. At times rushed his mechanics and throws
  • At times left some throws on the field that were there. Result was leaving the pocket either too early or late
  • Needs to develop better feel for picking up his drop tempo versus blitz/pressure. Everything happens faster
  • Much to learn about both offense and defense at next level. WMU pass game was elementary by NFL standards
Other
  • Eleby played three years at Western Michigan after coming out of Missouri as a 3-star prospect, with only a few Power 5 offers. Eleby started his final two seasons at WMU, finishing his college career with a strong 2021 season, throwing 23 TD and only 6 interceptions.
  • Western Michigan passing game, in normal down and down distance situations, featured a heavy dose of quick game, one-read, and no-read concepts. It was a basic pass game that did not put a lot of decision-making burden on Eleby.
  • On third downs, the WMU pass game expanded (as all third-down pass games must): Hi-low concepts, dagger concepts, mesh, smash, slot fade. WMU featured a lot of intermediate and vertical route concepts on third down, asking Eleby to take deeper drops and read it out.
Transition

Eleby was a fun QB to evaluate, especially on third down, when he was consistently effective working out of the pocket. When you watch his tape, you see a QB that does not check a lot of the boxes you ideally want in terms of physical traits and athleticism, but overall there was an efficiency to his game that showed up within the context of the Western Michigan passing game. Eleby is not as big and physical as you'd like, and his arm would be above average but nothing more by NFL standards, but he played with an excellent feel for the timing and rhythm of the WMU pass game, delivering with consistent ball placement and showing pocket poise and subtle movement when demanded. Eleby also showed a sense of progression reading in the dropback passing game, which was consistently evident on third down, when he was asked to take deeper drops and read it out depending on the route concepts/combinations. There were certainly areas in which Eleby must improve and weaknesses that must be addressed with coaching, but the more I watched his tape the more I thought Eleby has a chance to develop into a starting NFL QB with the right team, the right scheme, and the right coaching staff. Eleby must be in an offense with a run game foundation in which play action, RPO, and quick game concepts are foundational parts of the equation, but there is no question he can operate and execute the dropback passing game that demands progression reads and throws (we saw that on his Western Michigan tape). The traits and overall skill set are not high level, but in the right offense (with enough players around him), Elebt can execute an NFL offense as a ball distributor with enough mobility to run the designed boot game and make the occasional second-reaction play.

Sam
Howell
Junior
QB
North Carolina
Tar Heels
North Carolina Tar Heels Logo
HEIGHT 6' 0 5/8" HANDS 9 1/8"
WEIGHT 218 lbs CONE --
40 TIME -- BROAD --
Strengths
  • Short but solidly built QB with an over-the-top delivery and the arm strength to drive the ball with velocity
  • Good athlete with the quick feet to both move within the pocket and make plays outside the pocket
  • Flashed the patience and pocket poise to work through progressions and make late-in-the-down throws
  • Threw an excellent deep ball with both proper trajectory and touch, and consistently precise ball placement
  • Playmaking dimension with ability to make second-reaction movement throws and runs. A featured part of Howell's game
  • Gives an offense the designed QB run game and zone read game. Strong competitive runner with RB traits
  • Designed runs and second-reaction runs stood out most on tape. That was the strength of his game in 2021
  • Highly competitive with outstanding playing personality. Battles and competes. Mentally and physically tough
Weaknesses
  • Will need to learn the NFL play-action pass game from under center: did not throw a pass under center in 2021
  • Consistently showed a tendency to leave throws on the field. Did not turn it loose when throws were there
  • Too often left the pocket when first read was taken away. Must develop more patience and pocket movement
  • Not a natural timing and anticipatory thrower. Too often waited to see it before turning it loose: A "see-it throw-it" QB
  • Much to learn as to NFL pass game concepts and reading progressions within pocket structure: a work in progress
  • Ball placement at times erratic with too many missed layups. Must develop better touch and pace on short throws
Other
  • Howell was a three-year starter at North Carolina, after coming out of the state of North Carolina as a consensus 4-star recruit and a top 100 prospect nationally. Howell set multiple school passing records and finished his career third in ACC history with 92 passing TD.
  • Howell has extensive experience with the RPO game and the zone read game. The designed QB run game with multiple run game concepts was a foundational element of North Carolina's offense.
  • My sense watching the North Carolina passing game was that the route and progression concepts did not consistently define reads and throws for Howell and put him in a position where leaving the pocket and running was his best option, and he is good at it.
Transition

Howell will be an interesting evaluation as you project and transition him to the NFL. He is shorter than you ideally want, but he is solidly and compactly built with a strong frame and high level competitiveness. There is no question he possesses NFL traits with a strong arm that can drive the ball at the intermediate and deeper levels, and a running dimension that gives an offense both the designed QB run game and second-reaction movement plays. He was almost exclusively a pre-determined thrower in North Carolina's pass game and the issue with Howell is that he is not a naturally comfortable pocket QB with a refined sense of timing and rhythm within the structure of a detailed passing game. So the question becomes this: can he be taught that at the NFL level, or will he always be a higher-level traits player without the needed feel for playing the position from the pocket? The high percentage of Howell's timing and rhythm throws at North Carolina came on RPO concepts and bang play-action concepts and you cannot build an NFL passing game on solely that. Howell showed enough flashes as a pocket passer to get people excited, and he certainly has the arm talent demanded to succeed in the NFL, but much of his development will depend on coaching and scheme and his capacity to learn. There is something to work with from a traits standpoint, but can Howell become more refined, nuanced, detailed, and disciplined as a pocket QB? That's the question that must be answered. Howell cannot play in the NFL the same way he played at North Carolina with the strong emphasis on designed QB runs. He will need to develop and mature as a pocket QB to have any viable chance for meaningful success.

Kenny
Pickett
Senior
QB
Pittsburgh
Panthers
Pittsburgh Panthers Logo
HEIGHT 6' 3 1/4" HANDS 8 1/2"
WEIGHT 217 lbs CONE --
40 TIME 4.73 BROAD 121"
Strengths
  • Comfortable on his shotgun drop into the pocket: balance, good ball carriage, plants and sets with firm base
  • A touch-and-pace thrower more than a power thrower. Increased velocity when needed, but not a big arm
  • Showed a feel for the demanded anticipation and timing on spot throws on out cuts outside the numbers
  • Progression reading traits that, at times, showed a strong sense of elimination and isolation. Marriage of feet and eyes
  • Worked from trips side to the back side dig with a refined sense of timing - you don't see that often in college QBs
  • Showed understanding of safety rotation and movement to define reads and throws; decisive and aggressive
  • Showed the controlled movement to navigate and manage the pocket. Moved and reset with eyes downfield
  • Second-reaction mobility is controlled and calculated. Can make plays outside of structure throwing and running
  • Rarely got stuck in the pocket. Delivered within timing and structure, or broke the pocket to make a play
  • Athletic and competitive. Made plays with his legs when needed. Played with an aggressive physical edge
  • Well-schooled in multiple NFL passing game concepts with the reads and progressions that define them
  • Worked all 3 levels of the defense with the different drops, timing, and progression reads demanded at each one
Weaknesses
  • Hand size and arm strength will be debated. Pickett has small hands and does not have a live loose arm. How important is that?
  • At times could be a little sloppy with his drop and set, not planting with a firm base, resulting in being not ready to throw the ball
  • Snaps in which he had throws based on the route concept versus the coverage and didn't turn it loose
  • Too many snaps in which he broke the pocket early overreactive to pressure, leaving clean throws on the field
Other
  • Pickett was a four-year starter at Pittsburgh with 49 starts in his career. He finished as Pitt's all-time leader in completions, yards, and TDs.
  • The Pittsburgh passing game was almost exclusive shotgun and featured NFL concepts: slant-flat, y-stick, mesh, flood, dagger, hi-low, post-wheel, post-cross, double post, mirrored crossers, scissors, smash, back shoulder
  • Mack 31 yards versus Tennessee came on a staple NFL concept: flood opposite. Well designed and defined
  • Clemson high percentage zone coverage and high percentage zone pressures. They got too many free rushers at Pickett
  • Addison 23 yard TD versus Clemson designed boot with Addison corner route from #3 to trips. Great throw
  • Mack 39 yard TD versus Clemson: 2x2 reduced splits, Fire x 4 man pressure with 4 deep zone match coverage
  • Mack 23 yards versus Miami (FL) came on mirrored crossers-overs off power run action/ Pickett designed boot
  • Wayne 32 yard TD versus North Carolina: Pickett saw the bracket on Addison and hit the post opposite
Transition

Pickett has an overall skill set and traits profile that projects and transitions well to the NFL QB position with his desirable combination of pocket efficiency and second-reaction movement. He has good size and played with a physical and mental toughness and competitiveness that consistently stood out. Pickett was efficient from the pocket with a profile that is demanded at the NFL level: he showed vision, progression reading (with full field reading concepts), timing, anticipation, and precise ball placement, plus the athleticism and mobility to be a second reaction playmaker; Pickett can be highly effective as an executor and ball distributor, and that's where his game starts. The Pittsburgh passing game featured multiple NFL route concepts which demanded progression reading and did not present the simple schemed throws that define most college passing games, and Pickett was clearly comfortable with this process. As you look to transition Pickett to the NFL, some areas to focus on will be his arm strength (more measured than live and loose, which will be a factor for some but not for others) and his tendency at times to perceive pressure and break the pocket unnecessarily, resulting in throws left on the field (his second-reaction ability can at times compensate for that). My sense is Pickett will have to work through disguised coverages and late defensive movement at the next level, but all rookie QBs face that hurdle.

Desmond
Ridder
Senior
QB
Cincinnati
Bearcats
Cincinnati Bearcats Logo
HEIGHT 6' 3 3/8" HANDS 10"
WEIGHT 211 lbs CONE --
40 TIME 4.52 BROAD 127"
Strengths
  • Solidly built dual-threat QB with a live, strong arm to attack all levels plus excellent playmaking athleticism
  • Drop-back snaps with clean footwork and mechanics; good balance, firm base, and an easy natural delivery
  • Easy thrower with live, loose arm that generated velocity without much effort. Drove the ball when needed
  • Extensive experience with shotgun drop-back passing game. Good ball carriage with comfortable plant and set
  • Capable of outstanding pocket throws at the intermediate/deeper levels with timing, anticipation, and velocity
  • Throws on which he showed refined sense of timing and anticipation for the given route concept versus coverage
  • Willingness to make stick throws into tight windows versus man and zone with an aggressive throwing mindset
  • Made special throws that demanded velocity and precise ball placement. Flashed higher-level throwing traits
  • Showed the awareness of pressure and comfortable movement to slide in the pocket and make throws
  • Made reads and throws versus disguise and late movement defenses/coverages. No sense of confusion
  • Gives an offense the designed QB run game and the boot-action pass game. Good athlete with easy movement
Weaknesses
  • Little bit of an elongated delivery at times. A lot of motion in his delivery, which can negatively impact accuracy
  • Tendency at times to drop his arm angle just a little bit, and that caused the ball to sail resulting in high throws
  • Ball placement erratic on routine throws. Too many missed layups and "green light" throws that must be made
  • Left some deep balls a little short, on which he needed to get those out in front. Something he needs to works on
  • Tendency when he felt pressure to rush his mechanics and lose upper-body/lower-body sync and coordination
Other
  • Ridder was a four-year starter at Cincinnati, finishing his career with 44-5 record (only the third QB in college football history to win 44 games).
  • Cincinnati pass game featured NFL concepts like dagger, smash, flood, hi-low, snag-flat, slant-flat, post-cross, mirrored out routes with seam route, double post
  • One red flag with Ridder was his poor third-down production in 2021: 40-85, 47.1%, 5 yards per attempt, 4 TD, 4 interceptions, 10 sacks
  • Pierce 28 yards versus Indiana: Far hash corner throw versus disguised late movement to cover 3
  • Taylor 36 yards versus Notre Dame: Outstanding seam throw with timing, firm touch, and precise ball placement
  • Tucker 23 yards versus SMU: Timing and precise ball placement into a tight window versus cover 4
  • Scott 25 yard TD versus Houston: Well-thrown post on double post concept with firm touch
Transition

Ridder fits the old Bill Parcells QB commandments profile of being at least a three-year starter and having won more than 23 games at the college level. I have studied Ridder in each of his last three seasons, and his 2021 tape showed an accomplished QB with the needed physical and athletic traits profile to develop into a quality NFL starter. Ridder has size, arm talent, and mobility, plus a natural sense of poise and composure to his play. While Ridder has an easy and effective mobility to his game and can make second-reaction runs with his smooth athletic ability, he did not look to leave the pocket until his throwing options were exhausted, and he rarely broke down in the pocket unnecessarily. Ridder was comfortable playing within the confines of the pocket and the structured pass game, and there were snaps in which he showed subtle and efficient pocket movement to slide away from pressure and make throws. My sense is Ridder is best suited to begin his career in an offense with a run game foundation in which play action and RPO concepts are meaningful parts of the equation, but there is no question Ridder can operate and execute the drop back passing game that demands progression reads and throws. The caveat is Ridder must become less erratic with his ball placement, because that is an issue that would derail his development.

Carson
Strong
Junior
QB
Nevada
Wolf Pack
Nevada Wolf Pack Logo
HEIGHT 6' 3 3/8" HANDS 9 1/8"
WEIGHT 226 lbs CONE --
40 TIME -- BROAD --
Strengths
  • Good-sized QB with plus arm strength who can work all levels of the field. Looks prototypical in the pocket
  • Seemed to have a good feel for the pre-snap phase of the game. Very active before the snap of the ball
  • Showed sense of progression reading with a good feel for elimination and isolation. At times, a quick processor
  • At times showed a refined feel for the timing and anticipation demanded on specific throws like out cuts
  • The arm strength to throw from the far hash to the opposite sideline, which is a longer throw in college football than in the NFL
  • Showed the willingness to make tough stick throws into tight windows when down and distance demanded it
  • Showed the arc/trajectory, touch, and precise ball placement to make fade throws down the sideline
  • A good deep-ball thrower, laying it out in front of his receivers with excellent trajectory and precise placement
  • There were snaps in which he showed effective movement to navigate the pocket and find space to deliver
Weaknesses
  • At times did not bring his core through the throw, limiting weight transfer and negatively impacting velocity
  • Tendency to lock his front leg on his delivery, which resulted in pulling away from throws and losing velocity
  • Ball placement at times inconsistent. Not scattershot, but not precise enough on some routine throws
  • Does not have light feet and easy movement traits. Will not be a second-reaction player at the next level
  • Feet could be a little clunky and slow in the pocket. At times not efficient late-in-the-down in the pocket
  • There will be definite questions as to his ability to function effectively in muddied pockets. That's a major concern
Other
  • Strong was a three-year starter at Nevada, finishing his career as the Mountain West Offensive Player of the Year in 2021. Strong was not heavily recruited out of high school in California after missing his senior year with an injury.
  • Strong was an exclusive shotgun QB in Nevada's spread offense, with every drop back coming out of the gun. What stood out watching Strong was he did a lot of work in the pre-snap phase. Was he relaying the play call, or was he checking/audibling/changing protections based on defensive recognition?
  • One thing you saw a good amount of was Strong from the far hash throwing to #1 to trips on the opposite sideline (not something you see often).
  • Strong led a 53-second, 90-yard TD drive versus Fresno State with Nevada trailing by 8 and he made some big-time throws on the drive.
  • Doubs 23 yards on 3rd + 20 versus Kansas State: Aggressive throwing mindset and arm strength
  • Cooks 14 yard TD versus Kansas State: Condensed skinny post thrown with velocity and precise ball placement
  • Turner 21 yards versus Fresno State: Seam ball with velocity and ball placement versus cover 3
Transition

Strong in most ways projects and transitions to the NFL as more of an old-school pocket QB whose game is built on beating you from the pocket without any significant or game-changing second-reaction movement ability. For Strong to succeed as a quality NFL starter, he must master the nuances, subtleties, and disciplines of the position, with heavy emphasis on working out of muddied pockets and throwing with precise ball placement consistently. Strong showed an aggressive throwing mentality with the physical traits to make stick throws into tight windows with velocity, and his 2021 tape showed some excellent vertical throws with the needed touch and ball placement. My sense is Strong will need to learn to play under center with the conventional play action pass game given that he does not have the movement traits to work almost exclusively out of the shotgun. Strong can absolutely make NFL throws at the intermediate and deeper levels, and there were some throws that were special, so the question becomes the balance between his pocket throwing ability (higher level) and his lack of movement traits, both in and outside the pocket. Strong must be protected well and consistently, and he must learn to master the pre-snap phase to have any meaningful chance for success at the next level.

Malik
Willis
Junior
QB
Liberty
Flames
Liberty Flames Logo
HEIGHT 6' 0 1/2" HANDS 9 1/2"
WEIGHT 219 lbs CONE --
40 TIME -- BROAD --
Strengths
  • Strong arm with the throwing ability to drive the ball with power and velocity. An easy natural thrower
  • Firm touch and velocity to make tough throws into tight zone windows. Threw fade ball with good ball location
  • Capable of making outstanding throws at the intermediate and vertical levels. Both a live arm and a power arm
  • Showed some flashes of patience in the pocket and comfortable pocket movement, making late-in-the-down throws
  • Designed boot action and second reaction movement throwing and running featured parts of Willis' game
  • Gives offense designed QB run game with multiple concepts with his strong build and explosive vertical speed
  • A strong powerful runner who was tough to bring down in the open field - will that translate to the NFL?
  • Overall an explosive athlete and mover who can break down the defense and make plays outside of structure
  • Showed the athletic and throwing traits to make special plays off second-reaction movement. Can't teach that
Weaknesses
  • Field vision a concern. Did not show a refined feel for elimination and isolation. Too often slow to process
  • At this point, not a progression reader. Will leave the pocket when first read is muddy and rely on movement
  • Despite flashes, overall almost no feel for pocket movement or for managing the pocket. Much more a pocket leaver than pocket mover
  • Took far too many sacks some resulting from his lack of pocket feel. That cannot happen at the next level
  • Tendency to be a beat late on basic route combinations like snag-flat and curl-flat. Waited for it to define itself
  • Showed some scattershot tendencies as the season progressed. Missed badly on defined routine throws
  • Some interceptions came on pre-determined throws based on play call (3:23 in the 2nd quarter versus Ole Miss)
  • A physical competitive runner who initiated and took on a lot of contact. Will need to change that mentality in the NFL
Other
  • Willis began his college career at Auburn before transferring to Liberty, where he was a two-year starter. Liberty is not part of any conference and plays as a Division 1 independent.
  • Willis was an exclusive shotgun QB at Liberty. He has almost no experience playing under center with the footwork and drop timing that is demanded, in addition to having no experience in the conventional play-action passing game.
  • Douglas 41 yards versus MTSU: Willis second-reaction movement and downfield throwing ability on the move
  • 3:22 1st quarter versus Ole Miss: Willis not using motion to his advantage to win pre-snap, a missed opportunity
  • Shaa 30 yard TD versus Louisiana: Good read with an excellent off-platform throw versus front side pressure
Transition

As you project and transition Willis to the next level, he begins as an arm-strength and athletic dual-threat playmaking QB with a relatively steep learning curve as it relates to the NFL pass-game concepts and the reading progressions versus specific coverages that define the throws from those concepts and combinations. Willis was not asked to be a higher-level progression reader or to have a detailed understanding of coverages and coverage rotation, so that must be learned in the NFL and that will take time. A bigger concern will be his ability to see the field and make throws that are there, as he had too many clean throws left on the field at Liberty. The question is whether his run game dimension -- both designed and second-reaction -- can compensate for and camouflage his deficiencies and limitations early in his career, or is he a significant work in progress (my guess is different coaches will have different points of view on that subject)? One thing that did stand out on film was Willis' ability to make special second-reaction throws and runs, and that trait has become seen by some as a necessity in today's NFL/ It will be fascinating to see what team drafts Willis and how they structure their offense given the running dimension he provides. Willis comes into the NFL as a better pure thrower of the football than Lamar Jackson or Jalen Hurts. Some could see and evaluate Willis similarly to Trey Lance coming out of NDSU given his skill set and traits, but Lance is a much bigger man and played in a more detailed college offense. It's raw talent versus refinement/nuance/discipline -- that's the paradigm.

Bailey
Zappe
Senior
QB
Western Kentucky
Hilltoppers
Western Kentucky Hilltoppers Logo
HEIGHT 6' 0 1/2" HANDS 9 3/4"
WEIGHT 215 lbs CONE --
40 TIME 4.88 BROAD 109"
Strengths
  • Comfortable pocket passer with a refined and nuanced feel for his scheme. Decisive with his reads and throws
  • Dart thrower with strong sense of timing and rhythm of passing game. Ball came out quick on schemed throws
  • Ball placement was precise and for the most part consistent. Gave receivers run-after-catch opportunities
  • Made schemed vertical throws like slot fades or middle seam throws. Touch throws more than drive throws
  • An aggressive mindset thrower. Attacked one-on-ones versus man and stuck throws into tight zone windows
  • Aggressive throwing to the outside void at the intermediate level versus zone coverage. Tough throws
  • Showed subtle pocket movement to avoid pressure and deliver the ball cleanly. Quick feet in the pocket
  • Showed some second-reaction movement ability when timing throws were taken away. Saw the field well
  • Knew where to go versus blitz. Knew where his quick answers where. Did not get stuck holding the ball
Weaknesses
  • Arm strength not what you ideally want. Touch and pace thrower who cannot really drive the ball with velocity
  • Too many throws lost energy on the back end. Too many balls showed tendency to hang as they gained depth
  • Delivery tended to be deliberate, with too much time from hand separation to release. No snap to his throws
  • There will be definite questions as to his ability to handle pressure and make quality throws from contested pockets
  • Tendency at times to break down in pocket when quick game timing was not there. Not a late-in-the-down QB
  • Did not see much designed boot action in WKU offense. Can Zappe not handle that well?
Other
  • Zappe played one season at Western Kentucky as a graduate transfer after playing four years at Houston Baptist. In 2021, Zappe set FBS records for passing yards in a season (5987) and TD passes in a season (62).
  • Zappe ran what was essentially a pitch-and-catch passing game with a strong emphasis on quick timing and rhythm throws (including strong focus on WR screen game) to receivers who predominantly had free access off the ball and whose routes were rarely disrupted. There was also a good percentage of schemed concepts with defined one-read throws. The no-huddle tempo element helped, Zappe since it regulated the defense and produced clean pre-snap looks that resulted in rhythmic throws versus known coverages.
  • Zappe was efficient overall versus pressure from five or more men: 83-132, 63%, 7.9 yards per attempt, 17 TD with only 2 interceptions. He was sacked only 4 times when blitzed.
Transition

Zappe ran a high-volume passing game at Western Kentucky that featured a good percentage of schemed, manufactured, one read/no read throws, but he also showed the ability to work progressions and make throws that demanded higher-level timing. Zappe had outstanding command of the WKU offense, with a detailed and nuanced feel for the route concepts and the timing demanded to make all the throws, and what consistently stood out was his decisiveness and aggressiveness in turning it loose. The flip side of Zappe's 2021 tape was that you saw very few throws in which he had work late in the down out of contested and muddied pockets, and all NFL quarterbacks must be able to do that to have any chance for success. Zappe was an interesting 3rd-down study in that there were too many times he broke down in the pocket when there was no pressure, and other times he moved efficiently making second-reaction throws. What showed up with Zappe throughout his tape was his aggressiveness as a thrower (especially attacking one-on-ones outside the numbers) despite lacking the velocity to drive the ball, and for the most part that is a positive as he looks to make his transition to the next level. Zappe will have some significant challenges given the schematic nature of the pass game he ran at WKU and the high-percentage timing throws he made to open receivers in what was essentially pitch-and-catch. Zappe falls into the discussion with Colt McCoy, Case Keenum, and Taylor Heinicke as you project him to the NFL.